Finding a new dentist isn’t something most people enjoy. It’s a task that sits on your to-do list until your next cleaning is overdue—or something starts hurting. If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone.
Maybe you moved to a new neighborhood. Maybe your current dentist retired. Or maybe you just didn’t feel like your last dental visit was…well, a good fit. Whatever the reason, choosing a new dentist shouldn’t feel like a game of trial and error. After all, we’re talking about your oral health, and your time, energy, and comfort matter too.
If you’re not sure where to begin, here are six practical things to consider. These are the same things I tell family and friends when they ask for advice—and they make a real difference in finding a dental practice that’s a better match for you.
1. Read Online Reviews and Testimonials
Online reviews aren’t perfect, but they’re helpful, especially when you read between the lines.
Instead of just looking at the star rating, read the actual comments. Do people mention things that matter to you, like gentle care, clear communication, or a respectful team? Are appointments generally on time? Does the dental office feel organized rather than rushed or chaotic?
Also, pay attention to how the office responds to reviews, especially the not-so-great ones. A thoughtful, professional reply says a lot about how a dentist handles feedback and treats patients.
The goal isn’t perfection. It’s consistency. A dentist who has steadily positive feedback over time is usually doing something right.
2. Ask People in Your Life Who They Actually Trust
Nothing beats hearing about a dental experience from someone you know and trust. Whether it’s a neighbor, a coworker, or your cousin who’s extremely picky about healthcare providers, they can give you the straight story.
They might tell you how the hygienist put them at ease, how the dentist explained a treatment clearly, or how the office handled an emergency after hours. Those kinds of insights don’t show up in an ad or on a website, but they’re often what make the biggest difference.
So if you’re feeling unsure, a quick “Who do you go to?” could point you in the right direction.
3. Check Their Credentials
It’s too easy to assume that all dentists have the same training, but that’s not always the case. Before booking, check that the dentist is licensed, properly credentialed, and actively continuing their education.
You’ll usually find this info on their website, in the “About” or “Meet the Team” section. A dentist who’s a member of organizations like the ADA (American Dental Association) or AGD (Academy of General Dentistry) is staying connected to the constantly evolving world of dentistry.
Why does that matter to you? Because modern dentistry moves fast. A dentist who’s staying current is more likely to use the latest techniques and offer better, longer-lasting results.
4. Make Sure They’re In-Network (Or at Least Up Front With Costs)
Let’s talk insurance—because finding out post-visit that your dentist is out-of-network is a stress no one needs.
Before scheduling, call the office or check their website to see if they accept your plan. A good front desk team won’t just say “we take most insurances”—they’ll help you confirm your specific provider and potentially even verify benefits before your first visit.
If you don’t have dental insurance, many dental offices now offer in-house membership plans or payment options that help make dental care more affordable. It’s smart to ask.
Dental costs should never be a mystery. Transparency is a good sign of how the practice runs overall.
5. Location and Hours Can Make or Break the Routine
You know what makes it easier to stay on top of your dental cleanings? Not having to cross town in traffic to make a 10 AM appointment.
Location matters more than you think. So do office hours. Look for a dental office that’s either close to home, close to work, or close to wherever you’ll actually be when it’s time for your appointment. If weekends or evenings are important to you, look for extended hours.
The more convenient it is, the more likely you are to stick to your dental care routine without rescheduling three times or canceling.
6. Look at Their Range of Services—It Says More Than You Think
Some offices focus solely on general dentistry. Others offer a broader range of services, like cosmetic dentistry, implants, orthodontics, or even sedation options for anxious patients. That doesn’t mean one is better than the other—it depends on what you’re looking for.
If you know you might want teeth whitening, veneers, or Invisalign in the future, it’s a good idea to choose a dentist who already offers those services. If you’re someone who’s anxious at the thought of dental work, knowing your dentist offers relaxation methods or light sedation can be reassuring.
Having a dental team that can handle more of your care in-house often means fewer referrals, fewer extra appointments, and a more consistent experience.
One Last Thought: Comfort Matters Too
Finding a good dentist isn’t just about the technical skill (though, of course, that matters). It’s also about how you feel when you’re in the chair. Do you feel rushed—or heard? Judged—or respected?
A consultation or new patient visit is your chance to take note of those things. Ask questions. Pay attention to the tone of the office. A good dentist won’t make you feel embarrassed about your dental history—or pressured about treatment.
They’ll meet you where you are. Because that’s what good care looks like.
If you’re looking for a new dentist right now, take your time, but trust yourself, too. The right dental practice will feel right. It’ll earn your trust, not expect it. And it’ll help you care for your oral health in a way that actually fits your life.
And yes, somewhere out there is a dentist who gets that.
If you’re looking for a new dentist in Uniontown, Ohio, check out Peak Dental Arts. When you’re ready, we’d love to meet you.